A Look at the Short Stories of Raymond Carver
In “A Look at the Short Stories of Raymond Carver,” I’ll review the oeuvre of one of the twentieth century’s most gifted – and laconic – storytellers.
This article represents my first book review here on The Renaissance Garden Guy. It’s actually more of a books review. More specifically, I’m going to briefly give you my thoughts on the oeuvre, across six different volumes, of one of the 20th century’s most underappreciated authors, Raymond Carver. I’ve been a fan of Carver’s work for over thirty years – a BIG fan – and I want to tell you why. And I want to make some recommendations – six, specifically. But, before I subject you to my actual thoughts about Carver’s writing, I do want to get a couple of things squared away.
First, I’m nobody’s literary critic. I’m just a guy who loves to read, and who has an opinion.
Second, and more to the point, I’m recommending six volumes of Carver’s works. He’s known best for his short stories, and short stories are what’s in each of these volumes (with the exception of the last of my recs, which, in addition to his short stories, offers some other goodies – a great behind the scenes insight into Carver’s thoughts and feelings in the form of a letter he wrote to his editor, for example). The first four volumes I’m recommending are individual books of his short stories. Each of these four books has got its own group of stories except for Furious Seasons (recommendation two) and What We Talk About When We Talk About Love (recommendation three), which share three stories. The fifth of my recommendations contains selections from the first four books, plus some posthumously published short stories not found in those first four. The sixth of my recommendations is a collection of all of his short stories plus, as I’ve already mentioned, some great behind-the-scenes material, among other things.
So why am I recommending all six books to you when you can buy the sixth book alone and get all of his works, plus more, between one set of covers, all for one price? Simple. The literary purist in me wants to give you the opportunity to appreciate Carver the same way I did: one book at a time, from earliest to most recent. I feel that had I been introduced to Carver and his genius through my reading of recommendation number six here (which, again, also provides readers with insight into Carver’s thoughts and feelings at the time), it could have compromised (if ever so slightly) the impact of his work and the mystique of the man himself. Sort of like Dorothy and the rest getting a look at the man behind the curtain. You’ve gotta understand, when I bought my copy of recommendation number one, Will You Please Be Quiet, Please?, and read it, I was blindsided. I mean frickin’ blindsided. And devouring each subsequent collection afforded me the opportunity to be blindsided again and again. It was like knowing that the tiger was about to pounce, but still being shocked as hell when it did. You might want to try Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? first, just to see if you like Carver’s writing. Or possibly Furious Seasons, or What We Talk About When We Talk About Love. Maybe try one or two of them before you go all in.
Raymond Clevie Carver, Jr. was born in 1938 in Clatskanie, Oregon, and he died 50 years later of lung cancer in Port Angeles, Washington. I’m sure other Carver fans (and his loved ones, of course) would agree that the world lost him far too soon. His spotty educational pedigree allowed him to do some teaching and lecturing in the world of academia, but he spent a good part of his adult life working blue-collar jobs to support himself and his family. And the blue-collar world informed his fiction – in terms of both structure and content. Carver’s stories are all short. He wanted them to be written and read in one sitting. This brevity was generally necessitated by his work schedule. He wrote many of his stories while at work, during his various shifts. And those stories are typically populated with characters from society’s blue-collar, working classes. Again, he writes from experience here.
Carver’s writing style has been described as “Minimalism” or “Dirty Realism.” His stories are typically bleak and gritty, and the experiences of his mainly working-class characters are relayed in terse, spartan fashion. But what Carver is able to convey to the reader through this sparse writing is nothing short of miraculous. The hopes, fears, elation, and misery within the psyches of his characters, and the futility, incongruity, banality, and peril inherent in the plights of those characters, is delivered to the reader by Carver in the most economical, yet comprehensive fashion imaginable. Really, Carver tells you more with what he doesn’t write than with what he does write. I have never seen more ingenious and successful use of innuendo, implication, and suggestion than Carver’s. No other writer I’ve read comes close. Carver makes Hemingway and Chekhov seem positively chatty. In five words, Carver can tell you about the ruination of a relationship, the futility of a life, or the smugness of ignorance. With seemingly no effort, and with only the most cursory procession of letters, Carver causes the prosaic to shimmer with depth. Simplicity looms before the reader with gelid dimension and menace. Really, Carver is that good.
In the world of painting, the Italian Mannerist Master, Caravaggio (1571 – 1610), who is generally considered to be the progentitor of Europe’s fabulous 17th century Baroque movement, initialized a highly stylized form of chiaroscuro (light and shadow use) known as tenebrism (or Caravaggism) to infuse his scenes with heightened drama. All of the passion, fear, deternmination, and turmoil his painted subjects were feeling was captured and relayed to the viewer through Caravaggio’s tenebrism. Light and shadow alone conveyed all of the drama and told the whole story. I consider Carver’s use of implication and innuendo a sort of written (or unwritten?) tenebrism. Carver brings his characters to full, desperate life, and inserts them into their actualized worlds through the masterful use of just a few words. He implies. We infer. And we get the whole picture. Again, Carver is that good.
And the overall length (or lack thereof) of Carver’s stories is remarkable, considering the richness and profundity he delivers with each one. Most are under twenty pages in length. Many are under ten. One of his most jaw-dropping tales is two pages long. Remember, Carver wrote a bunch of these things while he was at work. He had to think fast, write fast, and read fast. These works are engineered to be quick reads. Each one is a thunderclap. Carver tells you a life’s story in the blink of an eye, using only a few more words than an on-line pizza order.
So what I’m giving you here is really a review of the style of Carver’s body of work – specifically his short stories – more so than simply an in-depth review of any one story or volume in particular. His work is unmistakable and his style is consistent. And in his last individual collection, Cathedral (recommendation number four), an evolution in his outlook is detectable. He demonstrates sort of an uptick in optimism. But his style and skill remain unchanged. I’m confident that if I can successfully recommend Carver’s style, then I can successfully recommend all of his short stories, and the volumes in which they respectively reside.
Below are my recommendations for six volumes of Raymond Carver’s short stories. I’m displaying links to each volume (in book form) from Amazon. If you’d like to order any of them, feel free to click on the image right here on this site and order securely through Amazon. I never see your personal information. I just provide the link that takes you directly to Amazon. I’ll say it again: what you buy and how you buy it is between you and Amazon. Also, feel free to click on the Amazon Kindle or Audible banners above if you’d prefer your books in those formats.
In any event, here are the recs:
Recommendation 1. Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? This volume contains short stories with copyrights starting as far back as 1963. I consider this the first volume of Carver’s stories. It contains such gems as the heartbreaking and terrifying “Why, Honey?,” a tragic novella in six-and-a-half pages (only Carver could pack a novella’s worth of story into six-and-a-half pages). And “What’s In Alaska?,” a little over fifteen pages of writing examining the treachery of banality. Plus many more greats. This book is as good an introduction to Carver’s genius as any. To learn more or to order this book here, directly from Amazon, please click the #advertisement link.
Will You Please Be Quiet, Please?, by Raymond Carver
Paperback Edition
Click here to learn more or to order
#advertisement
Recommendation 2. Furious Seasons and Other Stories. A collection of eight classic Carver short stories. Three stories from this volume also appear in his subsequent book (and my next recommendation), What We Talk About When We Talk About Love. They are “So Much Water So Close to Home,” “Distance” (subsequently re-titled “Everything Stuck to Him”), and “Dummy” (subsequently re-titled “The Third Thing That Killed My Father Off”). Also among these brilliant stories is the blistering, horrifying “The Fling” and, of course, “Furious Seasons.” To learn more, or to order this book here, directly from Amazon, please click the #advertisement link. (I don’t have a pic available of my own copy of Furious Seasons and Other Stories because it was lost in a flood several years ago. Every story featured in Furious Seasons, however, can also be found in Collected Stories.)
Furious Seasons and Other Stories, by Raymond Carver
Paperback Edition
Click here to learn more or to order
#advertisement
Recommendation 3. What We Talk About When We Talk About Love. Pure Carver, all the way. Three stories here are from Furious Seasons : “So Much Water So Close to Home,” “Everything Stuck to Him” (originally titled “Distance”), and “The Third Thing That Killed My Father Off” (originally titled as “Dummy”). The rest are all particular to the book. “Mr. Coffee and Mr. Fixit” speaks wistful volumes in just a little over five pages. “Popular Mechanics” (later re-titled as “Little Things” is a simmering two-pager culminating, as quickly as it begins, in an unspeakable horror. Plus many, many more. This volume is another great one with which to begin your explorations of Raymond Carver. To learn more about this excellent collection, or to order it here, directly from Amazon, please click the #advertisement link.
What We Talk About When We Talk About Love, by Raymond Carver
Paperback Edition
Click here to learn more or to order
#advertisement
Recommendation 4. Cathedral. Because Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? contains stories which had originally been copyrighted and published in a variety of different publications over a number of years (starting in 1963), it is sometimes not considered Carver’s first collection of stories. This interpretation would make Cathedral Carver’s third collection of stories. For the purposes of my review here, I am considering Will You Please Be Quiet, Please? Carver’s first book of collected stories, therefore making Cathedral his fourth book of collected stories. (Sorry about the confusion.) What matters most is that Cathedral marks a slight change in the tone and timbre of Carver’s stories. They’re still tersely written. Very short. But they convey a sense of optimism absent in his previous work. Since his first published works, Carver’s compassion for his characters has never been in question. This in spite of the fact that he so often places them in profoundly desperate and sad situations. Throughout the stories in Cathedral, his empathy continues, but the circumstances are not quite so bleak. There is that undercurrent of optimism, even excitement, evident in many of the works in Cathedral. This book is a Carver tour de force. To learn more about Cathedral, or to order it right here, directly from Amazon, please click the #advertisement link.
Recommendation 5. Where I’m Calling From. This book contains selected stories from the first four recommendations plus seven “new” stories not found in the first four books. I first purchased this book long ago in order to get my hands on the seven new stories, which were not included in the first four of my recommendations (all of which I owned and had read several times over by this time). This book was worth purchasing just for those seven stories. And what about those stories? As always, quick and potent. Spartan, yet moving. Plus, there’s a bonus: The last of these seven stories, “Errand,” is Carver’s version of the story of Anton Chekhov’s death. It’s partially a work of fiction, and partially fact-based. And it’s unlike anything Carver had ever written. It’s a remarkable example of a brilliant writer brilliantly mastering a brilliant new (for Carver) literary conceit. It’s also the last story Carver wrote before his death. Since Chekhov was one of Carver’s literary idols, I wonder if this “stretch” was motivated by Carver’s admiration of the great writer. This story is a classic in every sense and on every level. And in spite of the departure in style, it is unmistakably pure Raymond Carver. To learn more, or to order this excellent book from Amazon, please click the #advertisement link.
Where I’m Calling From, by Raymond Carver
Paperback Edition
Click here to learn more or to order
#advertisement
Recommendation 6. Collected Stories. This volume contains all of the stories from my first five recommendations, plus some additional items – most notably, a behind-the-scenes glimpse into the heart and mind of Carver himself – Carver the man, not the writer. This rare opportunity comes in the form of an edition of the manuscripts of the stories in What We Talk About When We Talk About Love (entitled Beginners) which Carver submitted to a former editor, along with a desperate and heartbreaking letter Carver subsequently sent to the same editor regarding this edition. Incredible. This book will give you all you could ever want of Carver’s short stories, and of Carver himself. To learn more about this remarkable volume, or to order it here, directly from Amazon, please click the #advertisement link.
Collected Stories, by Raymond Carver
Hardcover Edition
Click here to learn more or to order
#advertisement
So now you’ve got my individual recommendations and you’ve got my overall review of Raymond Carver’s style. Because that style is so consistent and so very slightly evolutionary, I can tell you confidently that if I make one specific Raymond Carver book recommendation, I make ’em all. Each and every story in each and every one of these books can only be Raymond Carver’s. The trademark brevity, the use of innuendo, the intensity – it’s Carver, and Carver alone. You’ll read his stories, and when you’re finished with them a few heartbeats later, you’ll wonder exactly what it was that just hit you over the head. Or punched you in the gut. In the time it took you to read what I’ve got here, you could have read any number of Carver’s stories, and really have been blown away.
Thanks for hearing me out. Cheers, and Happy Gardening (and Reading)!
The Renaissance Garden Guy is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Additionally, The Renaissance Garden Guy is a participant in the Bluehost, SeedsNow, and A2 Hosting affiliate programs. I earn a fee/commission each time a visitor clicks on an ad or banner on this site from one of these companies and makes a subsequent qualifying purchase.
Please click here to view The Renaissance Garden Guy Disclosure page.
Thank you for recommending this Author. I ordered one of his books at Thrift Books earlier this evening. I think even my husband will like the book.
Blessings
Thank you so much for reading the review, Ann. Carver is one of my all time favorites. I really believe you’re going to enjoy his work. I’ve never read another author quite like him. Wishing you and yours a wonderful holiday season and a happy and healthy 2023! Thanks once again!
Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you also. Have a blessed holiday season.
Thank you, Ann. All the best to you and yours!
Thank you for the very informative review. I learned a lot. I’ve never read Carver.
Thank you, Laura. I’m glad the review was helpful. The first time I read Carver’s work, I was literally blown away. Glad you enjoyed the review!
Your writing style is also compelling. It is a pleasure to read your posts
Thank you for your very kind words, Rick. I truly appreciate it. I’m glad you’re enjoying what I write here. I do my best to inform and entertain. Once again, thank you.
Great review, I just ordered your first recommendation. I’ll read it and pass it on. Your pictures were great, especially the one with the deer in the snowy forest.
Thanks, Kevin! I’m really glad the review was helpful. I’m sure your going to love reading Carver. Please let me know what you think after you read the book.
Can’t wait to get these books!
The stories are unforgettable – thanks for reading my review!